No Love For Blade On Left Circular Saws Hot

Porter-Cable Saw Boss 345What is with the lack of selection when it comes to circular saws that are blade on left? It is actually very surprising to me that manufacturers do not make their circular saws in both versions. Do they not realize that some people are left handed, or are like me and just prefer to be able to cut with my right hand, and see the cut at the same time. Cordless saws are blade left, and so are worm drive saws. Why should people have to switch between both, and not have a choice?

Some manufacturers actually do make blade left saws, but usually the selection is very limited, and so are the features. Out of all the major manufacturers, if you are looking for a 7-1/4" blade left circular saw with an electric brake, you have only one choice, the Porter-Cable 424MAG. With Porter Cable being placed between Black & Decker and DeWalt, who knows how long this saw, or the quality of the saw will last. Props to Porter-Cable, at least for now. All the other Brands need to get their act togerher.



Trackback(0)

TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (13)

Subscribe to this comment's feed
...
PutnamEco
Milwaukee make a blade left sidewinder also.
http://www.milwaukeetool.com/w...08_192137
Yeah, I know no blade brake, but they do spin down pretty quick. I've never really felt the need for a blade brake. Is it something you really feel that you need? I sometimes wish for a trigger lock, on my saws.

What I want is a decent (Makita or Milwaukee) blade right cordless sidewinder.

Sidewinders should be blade right. smilies/wink.gif

I'm right handed and don't like getting a pocket full of sawdust.Which my Makita cordless does with out fail.

Rigid and Hilti do make them, but I already carry four different battery chargers.
I am thinking of buying into the Hilti system, But their offerings are rather limited in the 36v range, and I think their recip saw is just plain weird.

I'm of the mind now, that if I find a tool that I really like I'll buy a replacement or two
so when the "new and improved" (read cheaper and less functional) tool replaces it, I'm not out of luck.



Roger Sandoz , Tuesday, 09 December 2008 1:29 PM
...
Chris
A co-worker of mine has that saw, and I enjoy using it, except for the weight and lack of dust exhaust. This, like I said above, shows the lack of features when compared to the same saw in a right handed version. The right version, does have a side dust exhaust. This one the biggest complaints I have about the left version.

I don't know that I need a brake, I was just pointing out that if one is needed, you only have one choice.

Every one of my co-workers uses a blade left circular saw... Maybe it is just a finish carpenter thing.
Chris Rodenius , Tuesday, 09 December 2008 1:50 PM
Re:Every one of my co-workers uses a blade left circular saw... Maybe it is just a finish carpenter thing.
PutnamEco
My first saw was a blade right sidewinder. Old habits die hard. It maybe a generational thing. Most of my peers use blade right sidewinders, most of the newer guys like blade left.

I like that I can hold the work with my left hand down on the bench and have the cutoff fall away and still have the saw stay up on the workpiece.
I also feel that I get a lot less debris all over myself. As I mentioned before, being a right hander and using blade left puts that sawdust extractor port right in my pocket.

Just out of curiosity, what saws are you seeing on your job sites? Here in NE Florida it seems that Dewalt (DW367) is the most popular followed by Makita (5007) then Ryobi, I'm continually amazed at how many people around here make their living with Ryobi.

Makita makes a neat little 5 ½" blade left trim saw (with brake) the 5005BA, although it is really no match for the Porter Cable 314

I am used to my worm drive being blade left, but tend to use it for different types of cuts. Mostly for off the bench/horse type of cuts.
Roger Sandoz , Tuesday, 09 December 2008 3:39 PM
...
Chris
Most of my co-workers use the PC Saw Boss, one uses the PC 423Mag ,and one uses the Milwaukee you mentioned. I never really pay attention to what the framers are using, but I still see a lot of Skil Saws.
Chris Rodenius , Tuesday, 09 December 2008 4:10 PM
...
SulSaw
I know makita used to offer a left bladed version of one of their popular models, but I can seem to find it anywhere, except for a trim model. The Milwaukee 6391-21 is another nice option for lefties. I've used the right sided version of the PC saw boss, it's a great lightweight saw,and I love the directional dust port.
I own a Ryobi trim saw, I never use the thing, but I too have noticed how popular it is with some. Only time I used it seriously is when I needed to make some cuts in Hardibacker and didnt feel like getting my good saw dirty.
A another time I used it in the HD parking lot to cut a piece of wood to fit inside the back of my car, I think some people in the lot thought I was Leatherface or some sort of maniac , welding a Ryobi as a weapon.smilies/grin.gif
Kevin , Friday, 12 December 2008 1:00 PM
...
SulSaw
wow, I just reread this thread it seems like I just repeated eveything everyone has already posted, I must be losing my vision, didnt see the comments.smilies/tongue.gif
Kevin , Friday, 12 December 2008 1:04 PM
...
Chris
The Milwaukee is high on my list for my next saw, but I will have to add a dust port. That saw gets dust everywhere, especially on my cutting lines.
Chris Rodenius , Friday, 12 December 2008 3:03 PM
Re:That saw gets dust everywhere, especially on my cutting lines.
PutnamEco
The Skil saw that I have has no dust port, yet the cut line remains visible. It doesn't fill my pockets with sawdust either.

I would really like to see some pics, if you do come up with a functional modification.

What is keeping you from choosing the Porter-Cables (423MAG)?
Roger Sandoz , Saturday, 13 December 2008 10:00 AM
i like the Milwaukee
Chris
The only thing keeping me from the Mag is the fact that I like the Milwaukee so much. Too bad it is almost a pound heavier then the Mag.

The Milwaukee is really bad at getting dust on my lines. I would get one of these after market dust ports, and probably add an elbow to it.

Nothing is for sure yet. smilies/smiley.gif
Chris Rodenius , Saturday, 13 December 2008 6:02 PM
...
PutnamEco
Those dust ports look more like an attachment port for a vacuum. I wonder how they work with nothing attached.
Roger Sandoz , Saturday, 13 December 2008 8:18 PM
...
Chris
Yes, I think you are correct. That is why I would add an elbow... so I can make it directional. It might take some modding to make it work to its full potential.
Chris Rodenius , Monday, 15 December 2008 2:54 PM
...
0
I know this post is almost two years old, but I think the selection in blade-on-left saws has grown quite a bit over the last few years. Not only are a few corded saws available with the blade on either side, but it seems like most of the cordless saws on the market have the blade on the left. So, things have improved in this respect in my opinion
Michel , Sunday, 10 October 2010 9:28 PM | url
...
0
Ever wonder WHY they make so many right-bladed saws? It's because of insurance companies and lawyers.

Insurance companies keep statistics on HOW people get injured. Then lawyers sue tool manufacturers.

There are two groups of people who get injured most: inexperienced homeowners and professional "cowboys." The inexperienced people forget they are dealing with a rotating blade and sharp metal teeth. When the blade is on the left, amateurs pull the saw from the board and let it swing too close to their legs. Sometimes they try to pick up the saw with the other hand. It doesn't take long to sever a tendon or open an artery.

Perhaps you have seen those "pros" who are in a hurry to "get-'er done." Well, they too make mistakes by forcing cuts, not using adequate work-holding and rushing. Since most pros favor a left-blade, and since pros statistically do more work, that makes insurance companies and lawyers blame the left blade instead of the user.

The REAL reason there are more accidents in the Bermuda Triangle is because there is more air and marine traffic there. Car accidents are more likely to happen at intersections where the most traffic conflicts happen. Naturally, saw accidents are more likely with those who use them more. Since pros use saws more than amateurs, and most pros use left bladed worm-drive saws, they are more like to suffer accidents. So between inexperienced "weekend warriors" and heavy professional users, left-blade saws get a bad rap. Actuaries who seldom have experience with circular saws don't know anything except what statistics tell them. Lawyers don't care if their careless client is an idiot, so long as they can make a profitable case.

It ain't the saw. It's the user. Left-bladed saws are safer for right-handed people, unless they are inattentive or rushed or just plain stupid. ...Don't even get me started on table-saw safety and lawyers!
OldSchoolSkill , Wednesday, 21 September 2011 7:43 AM

Write comment

smaller | bigger
security image
Write the displayed characters

busy

User Reviews

Rockwell Sonicrafter Deluxe 72-Piece Kit - RK5102K
 
3.8
Weed Eater One Riding Lawn Mower - WE261
 
1.2
Milwaukee 12 Inch Dual-Bevel Sliding Compound Miter Saw - 6955-20
 
5.0
Spring Tools 32R12-1 1/32 to 2/32-Inch Combination Nail Set
 
5.0
Klein 32500 11-in-1 Screwdriver/Nut Driver
 
4.3
Firestorm 10 Inch 15 Amp Table Saw with Stand - FS210LS
 
4.2
Weed Eater One Riding Lawn Mower - WE261
 
0.7
Staple Jack Staple & Nail Remover by Nail Jack
 
5.0
Milwaukee 7150-21 18 gauge Brad Nailer Kit
 
4.6
Yellow Jacket  50 ft. 12/3 extension cord - 2884
 
5.0

Submit News

Have Tool News Or Tips? We Want To Know.
This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Tags

RSS FeedsTwitterfacebookYouTubegoogleplus

Twitter

Latest Comments

Keter Rolling Tool C...
I have purchased the new KETER rolling tool box to...
Occidental Leather D...
Hi there, In regards to the bags, I have a large v...
Old 9.6 volt Maktia ...
I still got my old 9.6v drills it's a shame that M...
Craftsman Announces ...
A little pricey, but if the quality is decent, I'd...
Ridgid Trim Router A...
I've been eying the Bosch Colt for a while now. I ...

Latest User Reviews

1.
Tool Barn
 
4.1
2.
Bernzomatic Hose Torch - 19199 JTH7
 
3.3
3.
Accuride Customer Service
 
5.0
4.
Weed Eater One Riding Lawn Mower - WE261
 
1.4
5.
Rockwell Sonicrafter Deluxe 72-Piece Kit - RK5102K
 
3.6
6.
Weed Eater One Riding Lawn Mower - WE261
 
1.2
7.
Weed Eater One Riding Lawn Mower - WE261
 
0.8
8.
Milwaukee M12 Cordless Multi-Tool Kit - 2426-22
 
4.6
9.
Weed Eater One Riding Lawn Mower - WE261
 
3.0
10.
Power Tool Doctor
 
5.0